New Yorkers Pick Their Favorite Butchers

Just in time for Thanksgiving, a new poll of over 3,00 New Yorkers revealed the state’s top three independent butcher shops. The Meat Hook in Brooklyn took the number one spot, Skip’s on the Ridge in Rochester came in second, and the long-loved Esposito Meat Market in Manhattan rounded out the top three. Each shop has its own style, its own loyal following, and its own way of helping families prepare for the biggest meal of the year.

The Meat Hook Takes the Crown

New Yorkers across the state named The Meat Hook in Brooklyn as their top choice. This shop has become a staple for people who want high-quality cuts and friendly, no-nonsense butchers who love what they do.

Around the holidays, The Meat Hook feels like a neighborhood hub where people swap recipe ideas, pick out the perfect roast, and get guidance on how to pull off their holiday meal with confidence.

Skip’s on the Ridge Wins Rochester’s Heart

In Rochester, Skip’s on the Ridge has a reputation for its huge selection and, helpful staff. Whether you’re looking for a Thanksgiving turkey, a special cut, or just some great cooking advice, Skip’s is known for taking time with each customer. As the holiday rush builds, the shop fills with families placing orders and chatting with the butchers who have helped them through countless celebrations.

Esposito Meat Market Continues a Manhattan Tradition

In midtown Manhattan, Esposito Meat Market has been part of the city’s story for decades. This butcher shop lands at number three on the statewide list. The counters are packed with hand-trimmed beef, lamb, pork, poultry, and game.

With Thanksgiving almost here, families reserve turkeys, compare roast options, and ask for brining or carving tips. Even in the heart of Manhattan, the pace slows a little. Customers leave with their parcels wrapped in butcher paper and that familiar feeling that something special is headed to their dinner table.

Get our free mobile app

Those three butcher shops are fine and dandy but give me the Southern Tier stores in our own backyard any day. To see every states favorite local butcher for Thanksgiving, go here.